Browse Our Delicious Menu

Buffalo's Best Bagels Since '76!


Please pick the location closest to you and place your order at the store.

Pick up a bagel, Jay's secret recipe — New York style, hearth baked fresh throughout the day!

Our shmears are made with the freshest cream cheese available. You'll find plenty of hand-chopped vegetables, pure honey, strawberries and smoked salmon.

Our deli sandwiches are made on your choice of bagel, wheat wrap, NY rye, asiago, wheatberry bread or focaccia with your choice of lettuce, tomato, cukes, red onion, hot banana peppers and alfalfa sprouts.

View our Menu

Download a PDF version of our Menu

Menu is for reference only. Prices subject to change.